Need help picking out a putter?

I've been looking for a new putter for a while now. I love Scotty Cameron's (blades) but I'm not spending $400 on a putter. I also love Odyssey's I like the White Hot XG #1 most, it's a blade, and I really want a blade, I hate the extra weights on the back of Mallets, etc. I'm willing to spend about $120 on a putter, I'm willing to go up a little. What do you guys recommend? I'm short, 5'3" and I'm a high Handicaper, I can putt pretty good, but I'm not great. Also, I don't know if I like the white plastic on the face of the Odyssey, gets a lot of marks on it.